stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner
What we analysed
BVR’s AI bot is continuously reading, learning and evolving to generate reviews.
13,786 reviews
covering
47 products
for the category
Eye Liners
Experiential insights by users
About stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner
Overall Feedback:
71% positive
67% appreciated the easy removal process, but 33% experienced difficulties removing it
I always use Neutrogena's oil-free eye makeup remover and the eyeliner comes off easily.
I use Mary Kay's eye makeup remover to easily remove my eye-liner.
I had difficulty removing the hard and dry eyeliner from the container, and it was impossible to smudge onto my eyelid. It even fell out of the holder.
66% appreciated its long-lasting wear, but 34% noticed smudging
I had hoped the eye-liners would be more smudge proof.
Several of my eye-liners were brittle, dried up, and didn't work, snapping in pieces.
While applying the eye liner, tiny clumps come off on the eye lids.
67% praised for its rich, vibrant color, but 33% found it faded quickly
I experienced a severe reaction after using the new tube of eyeliner, including itchy eyes, swelling, redness, and tenderness.
