Maybelline New York Ultra-Liner Liquid Liner
What we analysed
BVR’s AI bot is continuously reading, learning and evolving to generate reviews.
13,786 reviews
covering
47 products
for the category
Eye Liners
Experiential insights by users
About Maybelline New York Ultra-Liner Liquid Liner
Overall Feedback:
86% positive
77% found it easy to apply, but 23% experienced streaks and unevenness
Applying the eyeliner was okay, but after it dried, it looked like electrical tape.
I find it difficult to apply eyeliner without making a mess because the brush is too short.
I had difficulty applying the eyeliner as it did not feather out with my separate liner brush and I disliked the tiny applicator brush that came with it.
74% appreciated the easy removal process, but 26% experienced difficulties removing it
I could not remove the eyeliner with water or makeup remover. It had to be peeled, which also pulled out some eyelashes with it.
83% appreciated its long-lasting wear
I have been using this eyeliner for over 20 years and think it is a great product.
73% praised for its rich, vibrant color, but 27% found it faded quickly
I love the dark brown color of the eyeliner.
After applying the eyeliner, it looked like electrical tape.
75% liked the precise, firm tip, but 25% found it too soft and flexible
I have not been successful with felt-tip liners and found this applicator brush to be the easiest to use.
All the liners I found at stores had a tip like a felt tip pen which catches on my wrinkles and gives a jagged line.
85% appreciated its water-resistant formula, but 15% were dissatisfied
I did not like the waterproof eyeliner as it did not apply well, looked like electrical tape, and caused issues while removing it, including pulling out some eyelashes.
