e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Felt Tip, Waterproof Liquid Formula
What we analysed
BVR’s AI bot is continuously reading, learning and evolving to generate reviews.
13,786 reviews
covering
47 products
for the category
Eye Liners
Experiential insights by users
About e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Felt Tip, Waterproof Liquid Formula
Overall Feedback:
82% positive
81% found it easy to apply
I find the eyeliner easy to apply with the felt tip pen and it stays on for a long time.
This eyeliner is incredibly easy to use and glides on smoothly without any tugging or pulling.
85% appreciated the easy removal process
I find this eyeliner easy to remove with a gentle cleanse, without any struggle or harsh makeup removers.
82% appreciated its long-lasting wear, but 18% noticed smudging
The eyeliner lasted for 2 months and it's a good deal for the price.
After 4-5 uses, the eyeliner dried up and now it is difficult to get anything out.
The eye-liner is not waterproof and came off when I teared, indicating poor longevity.
79% praised for its rich, vibrant color, but 21% found it faded quickly
After wearing it for some hours, my eye-liner fades away with sweat.
I noticed that the eyeliner is not waterproof and came off when I teared.
The eyeliner is not waterproof and came off when I teared.
I rarely get the desired precision with the eyeliner as it is patchy and lifts.
84% liked the precise, firm tip, but 16% found it too soft and flexible
The eyeliner is easy to apply with a felt tip pen and stays on for a long time. It is also matte.
The pen eyeliner has made my wings better and more precise. I feel decent with eyeliner but this pen eyeliner has made a significant difference.
After using the eye-liner 4-5 times, I noticed that the tip seemed to dry up and I had to press hard to get anything out.
All the previous brands I used allowed the cat eye tip to disappear.
Show more
83% appreciated its water-resistant formula
I have found that this eyeliner is waterproof and stays put all day without smudging or running.
